lallal

Why I’d Rather Be a Mexican Immigrant Than a Corporate CEO


The title specifies Mexican, but within the confines of this post I’ve selected the term “Mexican” to represent all populations of immigrants; part of the reason I made that decision is to parody–then educate–the large numbers of ignorant people out there who refer to everyone and anyone from Latin America as “Mexicans.”  If you’re interested in offending me and the 474,373,897 people that live in Latin America, and aren’t Mexican, then ándale, baby.  Go ahead, try me.

The other day I’m standing in line in CVS. The line was being held up, because a little boy of approximately 10 years in age was counting a series of worn dollar bills out one by one, reaching up timidly and placing each one gently atop the other on the red counter in a neat pile.  He painstakingly listened to the amount the cashier was asking for and tried to match it with the bills he fingered in between his small, delicate hands.  His mother stood on with his younger siblings, all three awaiting the completion of the transaction in nervous anticipation.  A quiet, pleading look of desperation remained fixed in the mother’s eyes, as her long, dark hair served only to shield a portion of her humble humiliation and loss of dignity.

The customers in line remained silent, as a thin but noticeable veil of awkwardness cast itself over the store. Right then, I heard the sigh.  She was middle-aged, with a highlighted blond bob, a leopard print scarf tied neatly around her neck and unusually large pearls dangling from her earlobes.  The frosty pink lipstick goes without saying.  I shot her my most deadly oh-no-you-didn’t death stare, and immediately felt my heart sink.

Impatient sighs transcend language barriers.

And in this case, this particular impatient sigh communicated a second meaning as well, one of apathy and rejection.

Now, raise your hand if you think that standing there at that counter would be easy, as a mother who has perhaps just newly arrived in a foreign country, can’t yet speak the language, doesn’t have a single ally, isn’t familiar with the customs or social norms, is confused, scared and uncertain of everything, including the people, and now has some cold, pretentious BMW bitch sighing at her? If I had to guess, I’d argue that coming to the United States has to be one of the hardest things she’s ever had to do in her life.  I’d also argue that what she’s doing sounds a lot like some other people I happen to know…

Yes, that’s right…lifestyle designers.

No administration could stop the tidal wave of immigration that swept over the land; no political party could restrain or control the enterprise of our people, and no reasonable man could desire to check the march of civilization.

Nelson A. Miles

That woman is not here in this country because she wants to piss you off.  She is not here so she can try and sneakily take advantage of the welfare system, she is not here to make every attempt to destroy the “culture” of the United States, and she is certainly not here on spring freaking break.  She is here because, despite the soul-sucking, spirit diminishing flat-out shitty challenges she faces each day, the quality of her life is still 10 times greater than it was before.

As aspiring lifestyle designers–and human beings in general–isn’t that exactly what we’re all seeking?  Greater quality of life?  Yet, our fellow Americans who gripe and moan and complain about immigrants are the same ones who would eagerly pat us on our backs, were we to make the decision to run off and relocate to Costa Rica–likely praising us for our sense of adventure–when, in essence, we are doing nothing more than what immigrants to the U.S. are doing: Seeking a better life. The only difference is that our definitions of what constitutes “a better life” vary. For a Mexican, they are coming to the United States largely due to a severe lack of economic resources in their home country, and are seeking to gain an economic advantage. (You actually think they wanted to leave their family and everything they knew behind, to come to a country where they’ll be routinely called derogatory names like “wetback” and be looked down upon?  Don’t flatter yourself, sweetheart.)  For us, we have already experienced what it’s like to have an economic advantage, and now we are in search of exactly what the Mexican likely left at home: tranquility, sense of community, an escape from the capitalistic pressures that define our society.

That said, beyond the fact that a sombrero is clearly way cooler than a comb over, I have much greater respect for a Mexican immigrant than I do a corporate CEO. It seems more virtuous to be a Mexican immigrant, putting your life, your pride and your family on the line in order to simply have the possibility of an opportunity to work–and not just any work, but hard, back-breaking work, which is what’s available to them–than a CEO who went to college (likely because that’s what everyone does these days; not because he had some yearning desire to learn), and then just leisurely fell into some company in which, by simply showing up everyday in one of five rotating suits, doing what he’s told and filling out some reports, he managed to work his way up the predictable corporate ladder.

The next time you see someone struggling with a language barrier, looking lost, confused, or needing help, I encourage you to remember, unless you’re Native American, you, too, were once an immigrant. We are a nation of immigrants.  We don’t have one dominant culture; English isn’t even the official language of the United States.  (Fact.) Hey, I have a good idea, everybody!  Let’s all immigrate to the United States for decades and decades, and then one day let’s just decide to shut our doors.  No more! Does that sound good to everyone? Have some compassion, people.

There was a time when we [the U.S.] had completely unrestricted immigration, when anybody could come to these shores and the motto on the Statue of Liberty had some real meaning. This was a country of hope and of promise for immigrants and their children, and as many as a million immigrants a year came in 1906 and ’07 and ’08. By 1914, roughly a third of the population was foreign-born or the immediate descendants of foreign-born…The fact that year after year hundreds of thousands of people left the countries of Europe to come to this country was persuasive evidence that they were coming to improve their lot, not to worsen it.

Milton Friedman

Anyone who has taken a leap of faith to be here, deserves to be here, and they deserve your respect and kindness, too. We should be grateful to embrace the wonderful cultural diversity that they offer us, in turn helping us to become more worldly, understanding, knowledgeable human beings.  Not to mention the contributions they make to our economy, contrary to popular myth, which you can read more about here, in a study conducted in August of this year that shows that immigrants actually help Americans move up. Read it. Although I don’t believe that immigrants hurt the economy, I do believe that if we could stop thinking in terms of monetary value for once, and start thinking in terms of what’s humane, the immigration debate would be a lot less of a debate.

The point I’m making with all of this?  Simple.

Homogeny is boring.

Immigrants are good people, too.

Don’t be a tool.

The end.

If you liked that jazz. . .check out some of these:

  • LEGALISTHEONLYWAY

    do people not realize what the word illegal means? I mean, honesty? I’m an American down in Costa Rica right now, since you bring it up. You know how i got here? I DID IT LEGALLY. I got a passport, I got a VISA and I’m here LEGALLY, contributing my $$$ to this economy. THANK YOU VERY MUCH. All the ILLEGALS can get OUT of america. Want in? DO IT THE LEGAL WAY. what a joke. And no i dont like CEOs either, thats a different matter entirely.

  • http://www.kylehepp.com Kylehepp

    This is the Best. Post. Ever.

    I want to send it to everyone I’ve ever debated on the subject with.

  • David William

    awesome post. im surprised i even came by, but damn that was good. also remember, our forefathers that were immigrants were also shit on. no one has ever liked immigrants. the irish and italians were the lowest of the low and most africans werent even immigrants. the hypocrisy is insulting. thanks for this post! we need more of this!

  • Pingback: This One Time, I Fell In Love With an Illegal Immigrant. Yes, That Actually Happened. | the middle finger project

  • http://www.cheap-nikeshox.com/ cheap nikeshox

    I like it, very good
    I like it, very good, Particularly in the Authority pages.

  • Rob

    Most Mexicans serve NO purpose in America other than to take from government services and commit crimes. Sorry you will think I am wrong but as a teacher in a All Mexican middle school in southern california I can tell you first hand what the student tell me. They nor their parents care about America and will never become American citizens, “why should we we do not need to to collect welfare”; they nor their parents care about getting an education; the girls all plan on getting pregnant before they are 17 years old and their parents will allow them and their bastard child to live with them; they do not need to speak English cause everything is in Spanish anyway; they can go back across the border anytime they want if they commit a crime. We do not need any more illegals to do mundane work (the work our kids used to do but now cannot get the job or do not want to work side by side with adult Mexicans) and the work our kids do not want to do the illegals and legals here now are having plenty of children that can pick strawberries and clean toilets-they will not get any better jobs and if they do not do these jobs they will either join gangs and commit crimes so the government houses them and feeds them in jail until they are let out to commit more crimes or they will just not work cause “hey the government will not let our babies starve”. You like Mexicans then you take them and take them all, including those born here under false pretenses back to Mexico with you when you leave.

    • TMFproject

      Interesting thoughts.  A bit overgeneralized, probably, but first hand experience counts for something.  I may want to recommend, however, a career change since it doesn't sound like you support any of your students, nor wish to see them improve.  And isn't that sort of what teachers are suppose to do? 

      It also sounds like most of your sources are probably the students you teach, which are children, and children of any ethnicity don't have a clue as to why they're in a particular situation.

      While I appreciate your experience, I think we forget why they're here in the first place, and have the tendency to dehumanize them and reduce them to mere economics–I don't suppose any of them really are thrilled with the idea of having to ride the tops of dangerous trains, suffer through desert heat and risk their lives just for kicks.  I imagine that if they're willing to do that, the alternative must be worse.  So can you blame them?

      Lucky us, who were born here and don't have to worry about such silly things as having enough food to eat or shoes to wear. 

      Sent from a Blackberry

    • Brian W.

      I hope you're not teaching English.

      Sorry, I couldn't resist.

  • Pingback: To my Generation: STOP JUDGING PEOPLE. « Ms Karen Au

  • TMFproject

    Ha, no.  You're suppose to reconsider your biases!

  • TMFproject

    With all due respect, I'm not sure how that's ironic, considering that it doesn't point to incongruity – I wasn't advocating for Latin America, I was advocating for North America to become more educated.  That said, your implication that the Pinochet coup was damaging is subjective in nature, and likely an opinion formed on already highly biased media sources.  While I'm not personally a Pinochet supporter, while living in Santiago I met many, many Chileans who were, despite the world's opinion.  They were able to cite various positive things that Pinochet accomplished.  Furthermore, I do believe that Milton Friedman was asked to come to Chile to consult on free market policies, which he did, and it's a widespread belief that the implementation of his policies not only improved the economic situation in Chile, but also contributed to the demise of Pinochet.

  • TMFproject

    You know, this question keeps popping up in my mind.  I can't help but wonder–over and over–if a lack of compassion springs from a lack of understanding.  More specifically, if everyone were required to travel to one foreign country as a part of receiving a college degree, would the world be a different place?  Maybe it wouldn't.  But….something tells me it would.  I am continually disappointed that as a human race as a whole, we are so quick to draw lines in between one another and go so far as to force differences that aren't even there, but are only perceived to be as a function of fear.  I truly believe this is one of humanity's greatest challenges, yet it's one of the easiest to remedy.  It's not rocket science; it's simply being open minded and accepting the fact that, hey — the world is full of different people and different places and we aren't the only ones in it.

  • tuesdaymondayfriday

    Being a white, pretentious, 20-something male accountant, I think I'm supposed to take offense to this. Right?

    • TMFproject

      Ha, no.  You're suppose to reconsider your biases!

  • Jenna

    It’s pretty ironic that you quoted Milton Friedman, considering he damaged Latin America a great deal, even working for the Pinochet government.

    • TMFproject

      With all due respect, I'm not sure how that's ironic, considering that it doesn't point to incongruity – I wasn't advocating for Latin America, I was advocating for North America to become more educated.  That said, your implication that the Pinochet coup was damaging is subjective in nature, and likely an opinion formed on already highly biased media sources.  While I'm not personally a Pinochet supporter, while living in Santiago I met many, many Chileans who were, despite the world's opinion.  They were able to cite various positive things that Pinochet accomplished.  Furthermore, I do believe that Milton Friedman was asked to come to Chile to consult on free market policies, which he did, and it's a widespread belief that the implementation of his policies not only improved the economic situation in Chile, but also contributed to the demise of Pinochet.

  • katiekasz

    Ashley, I LOVE this post. It is bold and powerful, well-written and conveys an incredible message. I have been next to the (as you say it–a term I love, fyi!) pretentious BMW bitch in line as she impatiently sighs and groans about someone 'holding up her very important day.' I mean really, how dare that woman who is struggling be such an inconvenience? Doesn't she realize her life, and the lives of her children, are unimportant?! (HA! WHAT A JOKE!)

    Your line– “Impatient sighs transcend language barriers” –rings more true than most people can imagine. On more than one occasion, I was on the receiving end of that sigh while learning Spanish and living in South America. The most ironic part about all of this is that those that get most annoyed and angry wouldn't dare step out of their 'english' comfort zones to experience being the receiver of the sigh. (I suppose, afterall, it is better to GIVE than to RECEIVE!)

    As you discuss with great fluency and clarity, most people raised here do not appreciate the hardships of immigrants, and TAKE EVERYTHING they have, and have been GIVEN, for granted. Perhaps if these 'BMW bitches' took a 'courageous' journey to another country to see how truly fortunate they are, they'd be more understanding–and less likely to sigh.

    Nice work, Ashley. Thanks for the great read!  :-)

    • TMFproject

      You know, this question keeps popping up in my mind.  I can't help but wonder–over and over–if a lack of compassion springs from a lack of understanding.  More specifically, if everyone were required to travel to one foreign country as a part of receiving a college degree, would the world be a different place?  Maybe it wouldn't.  But….something tells me it would.  I am continually disappointed that as a human race as a whole, we are so quick to draw lines in between one another and go so far as to force differences that aren't even there, but are only perceived to be as a function of fear.  I truly believe this is one of humanity's greatest challenges, yet it's one of the easiest to remedy.  It's not rocket science; it's simply being open minded and accepting the fact that, hey — the world is full of different people and different places and we aren't the only ones in it.

  • Deb

    Hi, Ashley -

    I love your discussion of immigrants!  Here are 2 great resources.  The first really shows immigration to the US over time, and how (if your ancestors didn't come over as slaves) we're all descendants of immigrants.  The number of current Mexican immigrants is stunning.
    The second is a fantastic 30 Days episode on the experiences of Mexican immigrants — of what they'd have to come home to if they were sent back to Mexico.

    http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2009/03/10/u…
    http://vod.fxnetworks.com/fod/play.php?sh=thirt… (Choose the episode “Immigration” in season 2.)

  • Deb

    Hi, Ashley -

    I love your discussion of immigrants!  Here are 2 great resources.  The first really shows immigration to the US over time, and how (if your ancestors didn't come over as slaves) we're all descendants of immigrants.  The number of current Mexican immigrants is stunning.
    The second is a fantastic 30 Days episode on the experiences of Mexican immigrants — of what they'd have to come home to if they were sent back to Mexico.

    http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2009/03/10/u…
    http://vod.fxnetworks.com/fod/play.php?sh=thirt… (Choose the episode “Immigration” in season 2.)

    • TMFproject

      Deb – These resources you posted are fantastic- thank you so much for sharing them!!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/teevee Teevee Aguirre

    Thank you.
    I am Mexican. I was born in Mexico and my parents migrated here to give us an opportunity for a better life. My mother risked our lives to get us across the border illegally and here I am now. Thankful. Grateful. Blessed.

    I read a lot about how we have ruined this great country and from time to time come across someone with a more realistic and compassionate point of view. I wrote something on my blog that touches on this a bit and would like to share:

    http://teeveeaguirre.com/illegal-aliens-and-imm…

    I am pretty excited to have stumbled across your blog! :)

    Thank you again.

    • TMFproject

      Teevee -

      I'm so honored to have you come by the blog and make a comment – thank YOU for that.  I don't know what it stems from; many would argue a severe desire to protect the economy/”culture” of the US, but I tend to think it comes down to simple xenophobia and lack of understanding of the issues at hand.  A lot of people see the results, i.e. immigrants here, there and everywhere, but don't take the time to educate themselves as to why they're here in the first place. 

      I checked out your blog – keep it up, brotha!  Que estes bien, y que mantengamos en contacto!

  • http://www.thelifething.com/ Jonny | thelifething,com

    Well said Tiger

  • TMFproject

    Hypocritical is the key word!!!!!!!!!  Thank you for pointing that out.  24AheadDotCom has another perspective that I'd like to address, so I'll be discussing this elsewhere in the comments section as well.  Though I'll say this: It's interesting to note TIME as a variable, here, and the impact it seems to have on whether we are considered citizens or immigrants.

  • TMFproject

    That's incredible and, in my opinion, a sound justification on behalf of the employers.  The U.S., in general, is dominated by an overwhelming sense of entitlement, the repercussions of which may have aided us in our quest to become that super power, but have also served to render us spoiled, bratty and selfish.  Expat Alley (http://www.expatalley.com) just wrote a blog post that differentiated between “being proud to be an American” versus “being grateful to be an American,” and advocated for the latter on the grounds that we haven't done anything to be proud of, yet are fortunate to reap the benefits of those who came before us and did the labor to get us to where we are today.  Simply by association, there are many that run around screaming cries of American pride, yet often do so based on the fact that we have more money than everyone else.  Fucking great.  Now show me who you are as a human being, not just a money making machine.

    Hey, that rhymed.  :)

  • http://www.awesomeandroidapps.com/ Brian W.

    Ash!  Your first troll!  I'm so proud.

  • http://24Ahead.com 24AheadDotCom

    This is an incredibly stupid post, including the false statement that we're all immigrants. In fact, this is the U.S., a legal entity which includes the concept of citizenship. We're citizens, not immigrants. The blogger also needs to learn about the phrase “noble savage”, and most of all needs to learn who she's ultimately helping. In fact, she's being a useful idiot for the corporations that she pretends to oppose (and also for the corrupt oligarchy of MX). She's supporting a Darwinistic policy where those fit enough to cross the desert get to stay; see this.

    Things look a whole lot different if you're familiar with all the facts of this issue.

    • kathy

      24Ahead.com…..please read the book i mentioned above and then we can talk.

    • TMFproject

      I'm so glad you stopped by to spread some cheer.  Thanks!  I also appreciate the opportunity to view some other sides of the issue–grateful for the link. 

      You clearly state on your website that you are to the right, which comes as no surprise.  I was a little disappointed, though, to find that no where do you provide some sort of identity for yourself; I was hoping to have a gander at your family tree.  Shoot!  Maybe next time. 

      While I certainly get a kick out of being called an idiot by a faceless entity, I'll humor your argument and dignify it with a response, in the name of standing up for the people I originally intended to give a voice to.  Hope you subscribed to follow-up comments.

      1.  “We're citizens, not immigrants.”  I'm not even sure that I need to counter this statement; the two are not mutually exclusive.  You might have had the good fortune to have been born here and, thus, a citizen, but where did your ancestors come from?  Were they automatic citizens?  Or were they immigrants first? 

      2.  “…and most of all needs to learn who she's ultimately helping. In fact, she's being a useful idiot for the corporations that she pretends to oppose.”  Aw, so sweet.

      I think the intention of my post should be made clear, since it seems to have been misinterpreted.  The purpose was not to say, “Hey!  Come to the United States!  You can have a better life here!” (And then ignorantly not realize that they are the foundation of capitalism.) The purpose was rather to say, “Hey, so you're here.  You're going to come regardless of what 24AheadDotCom has to say about it, or what I have to say about it.  And I understand your plight.  And hey, you know what?  I'm a human being, too.  You must be really scared.  I want to extend my compassion to you instead of being an unfeeling ass.” 

      Along those same lines, “the corporations that she pretends to oppose” requires further address.  I'm not sure where you got the idea that I oppose corporations.  I don't.  And if that's the case, then I'm not “pretending” to oppose them, either.  So, while your allegations fit nicely into your prose, they were, unfortunately, not much more than an assumption based on……?  What I am opposed against, however, are people who devote their entire lives as a cog in a wheel to a corporation, never realizing their actual insignificance in relation.  People are living, breathing human beings capable of feeling, and, by extension, doing other things as well that allow them to capitalize upon this cute little biological detail.  Corporations are none of those things…so why spend your life devoted to something that could care less about you?  (Except in terms of how much profit you translate into.) Corporations are fine, and there are plenty of people who are happy working in the them.  I'm not.  Some others aren't, either.  And those are the people that I'm talking to. 

      3.  Last but not least – You offer a classic neoconservative position on illegal immigrants that lends itself to an inherent contradiction: You hate them, but our economy requires their exploitation.  Capitalism requires a cheap, oppressed labor source–desperate and silenced immigrants have always been an easy target.  So, not only are you using them so you can afford to prance around in Prada sunglasses, on top of it, you're treating them like they're the problem…when, in fact, they support your lifestyle.  Well done! 

      Hmmm…..You're right.  Things DO look a lot different if you're familiar with all the facts of this issue.

    • http://rulesoptional.com Andrew MacPherson

      24Ahead.com: Illegal immigration, news, politics, media bias, and other joys at the intersection of xenophobia and ethnocentrism.

  • Carol

    Hey Ashley …

    I have said it before, I will repeat it now … you are inspiring!

    I am always excited when I see you posted something new … and most of what you write resonates with me … granted I am not a United States-ian (for many reasons I have issues with giving people from the United States the term 'American' for freaking obvious reasons!) I love being a foriegner … I love being that person that is blankly staring into the eyes of a foriegn store clerk or resturant personal and being confused … I love that sense of happiness and achievment that comes from finally understanding something in a language you don't speak.

    Recently, last week, I went to visit my parents in Whitehorse (northern Canada) and was shopping in the grocery store and I turned and looked at my Mother and said you know while travelling I take all sorts of photos with cans and fruits and things I think are intriguing and now I realize how freakin odd that would be … I wonder what people must think when I do that. Because, I would think it was strange if I say someone in the superstore was snapping photos of Saskatoon Berries. Jah!

    I love living in the ignornace that surronds you being in a place where you don't speak the language but feel a twing of hurt for those that do it here….

    Anyway – blah, blah … rant, rant … scorpian, dung beatle, meow, meow … A month ago I started the screening process to work at the Multicultual center where I live to help people in those situations. We may be the land of the free but so many consequences come along with that freedom.

    Keep on doing what you do Ashley – it's Awesome!

    Carol

    • http://rulesoptional.com Andrew MacPherson

      This common refusal or begrudging reluctance to refer to people from the “United States of America” as 'Americans' is always somewhat _______ to me. Part of the reason is because nobody seems to have an alternative based on the official name of the country. I mean sure, generally pejorative terms like 'gringo' are awesome, but Canadians (among others) are gringos as well, so we can't even claim that one. I got an extra laugh because the “United States-ian” demonstrates what I mean. It's also still a fail because Mexicans (the E.U., et cetera) would be up in arms because they are groups of “united states” as well.

      To everyone in the world: U.S. citizens being referred to as 'Americans' is not a nefarious social conspiracy to mentally subjugate the minds of the other residents of the continents of the Americas that we all voted on after being persuaded by Dick Cheney. It simply follows the convention of adapting a term for the people as a shortened version of the name of the country. Please note the distinction between country and continent. It's simply an unfortunate semantic issue. When another country named America shows up, I'll happily consider conceding the term.

      Now, before anyone accuses me of blatant flag waving, my solution and defense can be found in my article arguing that the entire construct of nations amounts to bigotry rooted in outmoded group dynamics.

  • http://www.WanderingEarl.com/ Earl

    Having just returned from a few months in Mexico, I was surprised at how many Mexicans I met who had spent time in the US but then made the even tougher decision to return home. Usually, they explained to me that despite the opportunity for earning decent money, they found life to be even more difficult up north. This was due to how they were treated, being away from family (as you mentioned) and what they often referred to as an American lifestyle that involves only work.

    It's a interesting that people who risk everything to have a chance at living in the USA decide that their simpler, poorer, community-based life back in Mexico (or wherever) is preferable. It's almost as if these people are reverse life-designers. They're giving up dreams of wealth, status and power, for a simpler, cheaper quality of life. The only difference is that we must venture abroad to find such a lifestyle and they just need to return home.

    Well, that's my random thoughts…

    • TMFproject

      Yes!  I've come across this scenario a few times as well in my travels.  It reminds me of that well-known story of the American who retired and expatriated abroad, where he ended up mentoring a young boy.  He saw potential in the boy, so he offered to help him do x, y and z to become “successful.”  At first, the boy was interested, but then as he posed more and more questions, he finally asked, “So, what do you do at the end when you've got plenty of money.  Then what?”  And the American man said, “Well, then, you retire somewhere abroad and watch the sun set all day.  Precisely what the young boy was already doing every day. 

      Love that story.

  • http://www.thewaythatyouwander.com/ Nate

    Immigrants ARE good people. In the area I live in we've had a large suge of Somalian immigrants over the last several years. It really bothers me when people are outwardly mean to them for no reason at all. I've always gone out of the way to say hello to them and be nice, just because so many people are jerks. Great thoughts once again, Ashley.

    • TMFproject

      I had a professor who worked extensively with Somali refugees; to hear their stories is heart breaking.  Also, the challenges they faced were so much greater than most can even grasp–to hand them a notebook, for example, they would flip it over, turn it around…unsure of which was the front versus the back or what to do with it in general.  Now there's a freaking learning curve if I've ever seen one.  We've got some of the bravest people here in the world right in front of us here in the United States, yet, everyone treats them as if they're not worthy of human compassion.  It's as if they were a different creature altogether.  Fear of the unknown breeds mad amounts of ignorance.

  • goat000

    Hooray post.  Love it.

    Couldn't find the link, but a couple months back I saw a study that concluded that recent immigrants as a whole are net providers of jobs – they create more than they occupy themselves.  It may have only considered legal immigrants though, not sure.

    The Native Americans are sort of immigrants too ;) Seems they walked over the Bering Strait land bridge 20000 years ago.  They do have everyone else beat by a factor of ~40 on the time thing, though.

    Though, be fair, the CEOs you're thinking of generally have done more than just show up for 25 years.  For every CEO in the 10000 largest companies in the US, there are a thousand others that also went to college and put in their time.  Those CEOs may have advanced on something other than real business merit – politics, subterfuge, etc. – but odds are they wanted it more and worked harder than everyone around them.  And I bet that for a lot of them, the CEO thing is their ideal “lifestyle design” – some even started the company themselves to get out of working for someone else.

    • TMFproject

      That's a shame, I would have loved to see that study!  And good point about Native Americans…although I suppose you could just keep going back farther and farther and farther and then no one would technically be a native, eh?

    • http://kylecooper.net kylecooper

      Gotta agree with Goat up there regarding CEO's. Every executive I've had the pleasure of working with, from CEO to CFO, has been genuinely passionate about their jobs and everything they entail. From leadership to number-crunching to keeping their customer base happy and returning. I know it's easy to rally against these high powered, well paid suits, but at the end of the day these guys busted their asses to get where they are and typically love the work they do. Not that the work they do is for everyone, most of all me, haha.

      It's been my experience that the two groups may not be that dissimilar (yes, I've also had the pleasure of hanging sheetrock with immigrants). Both took a huge gamble to get where they are, both work hard, and both are typically pretty happy people.

      Also, it seems like both get a bad rap from certain people ;)

      • TMFproject

        Hi, Kyle!  Thanks for your comment – I'll admit to using the term “CEO” just for the sake of a catchy headline (“Why I'd Rather Be a Mexican Immigrant Than Employee” just didn't sound quite as good!), but rather meant to make a broad comparison of Mexican immigrants, who are usually looked down upon & not given much opportunity, despite how hard some work, with some corporate Joes, who are revered and given plenty of opportunity, despite how little some work.  That's certainly an oversimplication and overgeneralization in many ways, but I just wanted to illustrate that sometimes, hard work doesn't pay off.  Socioeconomic background does, though. 

        Definitely have nothing against CEO's!  Heck, for a long time I wanted to be one! 

        Thanks for stopping by – glad to receive your comment.  :)

  • kathy

    WOW! well said ashley! the topic of immigrants (specifically from latin america) has been one that i have been very activist-like in educating americans. check out this book from aviva chomsky (not sure if she's related to Noam…) titled “They Take Our Jobs and 20 other myths about immigration.” it's a book every american should read! ROCK ON SISTA!

    • TMFproject

      I'm definitely going to check it out.  Thanks, Kathy!

  • Chris

    Kind of presumptuous.  Maybe she just didn't give a hot god damn if it took forever for her rugrat to count all the bills (Kind of like how I imagine you wouldn't :P )

    That aside, I like the cut of your gib!

    • TMFproject

      You're right, my interpretation of that woman's feelings in CVS was presumptuous; that said, I don't think the argument I make about Americans as a whole acting in a humane manner is presumptuous at all.  Actually, I think the reverse, in which people reek of smug entitlement, are the arrogant ones. 

      It's true that while this is certainly an oversimplification in many ways, and there are exceptions to every rule, I can't imagine that I'd be presumptuous to say that if there were genocide happening in your country, for example, and you were faced with the choice to either be killed or move your ass to a different country, in spite of all odds, and you did..that you'd be scared shitless, too.  Especially if you weren't welcomed, which would do nothing but compound the issue.  Right?  Not presumptuous at all.  Basic human nature. 

      By the way, I say all of that in the most congenial tone of voice…if you know TMFproject, you know I always like a good debate!  But seriously, thanks for stopping by and leaving a comment, Chris.  :)

  • http://www.fearlessendeavors.com/ Nate

    Yeah, I hate pretentious ass holes (pardon my language) who sneer at immigrants from Latin America and want to build a frickin' wall.  What.  The.  Hell.

    Basically, every frickin' person in this country is an immigrant.  The true native population of the Americas were largely killed and shunned away to reservations….a whole 'nother topic there.  I'm not trying to come across as a radical here, but it's so hypocritical to have anything against someone coming to America to start new.  NEWS FLASH: If you're white that's exactly why you're here.  At some point in the past few hundred years, you had a relative who left their home country to come here for a better way of life, whether it was to escape persecution or just simply live the American dream.

    You hit it on the head here Ash!

    • TMFproject

      Hypocritical is the key word!!!!!!!!!  Thank you for pointing that out.  24AheadDotCom has another perspective that I'd like to address, so I'll be discussing this elsewhere in the comments section as well.  Though I'll say this: It's interesting to note TIME as a variable, here, and the impact it seems to have on whether we are considered citizens or immigrants.

  • http://exilelifestyle.com/ Colin Wright

    Love. It.

    It's like in LA how many employers won't hire locals, only folks from other countries and the Midwest. Why? Because they know if those people made it out to LA and managed to survive, they work really frickin' hard and must be good at something. The locals are more likely to feel they deserve the job simply because they live there.

    The US became a super power because of the dream you're writing about here, and we'd all do well to remember that without these 'foreigners' we wouldn't have the high quality of life we do today.

    • TMFproject

      That's incredible and, in my opinion, a sound justification on behalf of the employers.  The U.S., in general, is dominated by an overwhelming sense of entitlement, the repercussions of which may have aided us in our quest to become that super power, but have also served to render us spoiled, bratty and selfish.  Expat Alley (http://www.expatalley.com) just wrote a blog post that differentiated between “being proud to be an American” versus “being grateful to be an American,” and advocated for the latter on the grounds that we haven't done anything to be proud of, yet are fortunate to reap the benefits of those who came before us and did the labor to get us to where we are today.  Simply by association, there are many that run around screaming cries of American pride, yet often do so based on the fact that we have more money than everyone else.  Fucking great.  Now show me who you are as a human being, not just a money making machine.

      Hey, that rhymed.  :)

  • Pingback: uberVU - social comments

  • melaniward

    So fabulous Ashley. This was a great read. My fave line “she's certainly not here on spring freakin break!!!” You nailed it – thanks for writing it.

    Melani

    • TMFproject

      Thanks, Melani – This one's been brewing inside of me for years on end.

Custom WP Theme created with love by violetminded & Amanda Farough Header by Marta Spendowska &PolishLab